FaithSolace.com :: Post a reply

FaithSolace.com
for Faith Fans

FAQ

Memberlist

Usergroups

Profile

FaithSolace.com Forum Index -> The Girl

Post a reply

Username

Subject

Message body

Emoticons





View more Emoticons

Font colour: Font size:

Close Tags

[quote="Ashes"][quote]I loved Odo's grouchiness and sarcasm lol! [/quote] I personally liked Tuvok's 'i'm-just-stating-the obvoius' kind of sarcasam more. BTW: I've overlooked you wrote you thought Tuvok lacked spark. I mean - he's a Vulcan! If he had any more spark he would have most likely been dangerous to the crew. Just remember what happened after he preforemed a mind meld with Suder. Or what Vorik was like in Blood Fever. Even Klingons aren't half as violent as out of control Vulcans.

[quote]Again, she's 70 light years away from Starfleet and she has to do what's best for her crew. And to be honest, there was no way she was as bad as Kirk! [/quote]

That's exactly my point! She has to do what's best for her and her crew! Starfleet regulations can't apply in situation like this, and she must at least bend the rules to keep them alive and get them home eventually.  I'm not upset about her breaking the rules , her rants about how important are they are what drove me crazy. Starfleet rules just can't be taken as anything more than guidlines when you're 70ly away from earth.  I mean - break the rule or don't break it - just please don't whine about it, there's already one Kim too many on Voyager.

[quote]As for the Maquis - of course they have to follow Starfleet regulations[/quote] i remember an intelligent dialog between Tuvok and one of the Maqui crewmen in an early voyager episode in which tuvok said that situation suggests starfleet crew will have to learn how to bend a few rules, and do some things the maquii way, to which the maquii crewman replied something like: if starfleet learns to bend some rules occasionally, maquii probably can learn to obey the same. At that particular moment i thought voyager would be the best ST ever. I never understood why  writers never pursued this further.

[quote]You can't have 'officers' punching eachother out whenever they disagree. [/quote] yeah, i know but Carey had it coming. :mrgreen: Besides a man stupid enough to provoke a half-klingon can't be the most brilliant engineer ever. :evil:

[quote]I don't think many people liked the 'crush on Chakotay' thing - (didn't they eventually drop it?)[/quote] Oh, please he was the main reason for admiral's time travel in the "endgame".  I mean - i don't think admiral janeways's timeline was so bad it needed altering. I agree prime directive can be bent on some occasions but messing with the temporal one is insane!

[quote]Quote: 
#5. The way she plays mother to Seven,Harry and occasionally Tom.

I personally liked that with Seven and Tom.[/quote] 
¨!#$%&¨!!!
Seven indeed needed guidence, and imho - doctor proved to be the best posible guide ever.

[quote]I actually don't remember her taking on board loads of people[/quote]... Icheb, and the borg kids,the One (27th century borg drone - killed himself), suicidal Q(eventually also killed himself), devoran inspector(betrayed them), some alien who had a crush on chakotay(her memory got deleted and she and left)... and these are just some of them....

[quote]Quote: 
#10. Just how many times did she loose Voyager?

To my knowledge, never.[/quote]
BZZZ! wrong answer :mrgreen:
I can remember at least three times even without cheking : once the Kazons managed to take it over, another time some strange species who imprisoned all crew in some artificial bio- habittat, then there were hirogens....

[quote] I think Kate Mulgew is a wonderful actress[/quote]
 :wink:  well, ok so we strongly disagree. (no hard feelings  :wink: )
 i've obviously had my expectations (from both character and actress) set diferently.

[quote]and as a point of interest - I don't think Jadzia was 'killed off'. Either Terry left or there was a problem with her contract - there's conflicting reports [/quote]
i didn't know that. thanks for the info :mrgreen:

[quote] Anyway - I don't think it would've mattered who was in command[/quote]
I however think it would matter simply  because characters as different as J.Dax and Janeway would have in no way acted the same in most cases, and no writer (except posiblly Noxon who is thank God in no way affiliated with ST  :wink: ) can't just ignore that completely. Ergo: different captain= different show. :mrgreen:

[quote]I've never seen The Clone Wars!!  I didn't even know it existed! I don't think it's been on TV here.  [/quote] I think it's been only on cartoon network. i'd post you some download links but unfortunatelly mine don't work anymore  :cry:  Oh and yeah, it's just 10 episodes per season so 20 altogether so far - i've mixed up numbers sorry.

Oh, and Nemesis - i didn't see it.

Well that's it for now... I'm off to sleep :mrgreen:

(btw: i know it doesn't really matter but shouldn't we move this discussion to a different thread or something?)[/quote]

Options
HTML is OFF
BBCode is ON
Smilies are ON

	Disable BBCode in this post
	Disable Smilies in this post

All times are GMT

Topic review