Sarah Michelle Gellar - Buffy Summers
Nicholas Brendon - Xander Harris
Alyson Hannigan - Willow Rosenberg
James Marsters - Spike
Emma Caulfield - Anya
Michelle Trachtenberg - Dawn
Azura Skye - Cassie Newton
Zachery Bryan - Peter
Glenn Morshower -Mr. Newton
Rick Gonzalez - Thomas
Kevin Christy - Josh
Sarah Hagan - Amanda
Beth Skipp - Unknown
Anthony Harrell - Unknown
Jarrett Lennon - Student w/ Coins
DB Woodside - Principal Wood
J. Barton - Mike Helgenburg
Daniel Dehring - Red Robed #1
AJ Wedding - Red Robed #2
Marcie Lynn Ross - Dead Woman