At the house, Tara is making pancakes for Dawn. Willow walks in with Amy. Willow introduces them and then Amy starts rambling about all the magic they did. Tara ends up leaving. Buffy walks in and Dawn asks her if she is ok. Buffy says she had an all night long fight, and that there's no danger for anyone else to worry about. Willow and Amy pulled all nighter too, and Amy goes home. Buffy goes upstairs to get rest. Willow goes upstairs and tries to shut the curtains with magic but she can't. She gets up to close them.

At the magic shop. Xander is still trying to find the monster who stole the diamond. Anya is looking through books too, but Xander finds that she is looking at bridesmaid's magazines. Buffy is there too. They bring up Willow again, and mention how Willow has made a new playmate to do magic with, and Buffy defends Willow. Amy and Willow are walking down the streets, and their powers are drained. Amy suggests they go see someone, who can help them do spells that last for days. They go to a dark alley and find a hot spot. Amy and Willow disappear inside to see Rack. Rack knows that Amy was a rat. His hands are giving off flames, and he touches Willow after he explains she's got to give a little to get a little.

Amy is spinning in circles and Willow is on the ceiling. They are both in Rack's inner office. As Willow looks down, she sees a forest, and sees a monster. She yells, falls down and passes out. Next, she is taken to different places and then wakes up. She is in her room. She takes a shower, and is weepeing in it. She takes something of Tara's and puffs it up so it appears that someone is in it. This puff person holds her.

Dawn is trying to cook peanut butter quesidillas They talk about the night before and Willow apologized for not coming home. Dawn can take care of herself. Willow offers to go see a movie with dawn, and offers to buy her dinner. Dawn thanks her and will remember to never invent peanut butter quesidillas. They leave a note for Buffy. Buffy comes home to find Amy in Willow's room. Amy is takng herbs and stuff from WIllow. Amy tells Buffy about Rack's and Willow's dependence on him and magic. Buffy demands where Willow and Dawn are. She is shaking Amy so much that Amy gets sick.

Willow and Dawn are walking to the movies after their dinner. Willow asks how things went with Tara. Dawn asks if they are going the right way to the movies, and Willow tells her she has to make a stop. She takes Dawn to Rack's place,and Dawn is waiting. In Rack's office, he is zapping Willow and she is in a bubble. She is flying through space. and sees the monster again. She starts screaming.

Buffy is at Spike's place, asking for his help to find Dawn. She mentions Rack, and he tells her that Rack deals with dangerous magic. At Rack's place, Dawn has been there two hours. Willow comes out, and her eyes are black. Dawn is mad because they missed the movie. As they are walking away, Dwn wants to just go home. Willow is acting intoxicated. The monster is following them. As Buffy and Spike are looking for the missing two, they start arguing about the night before and their kiss, again.

As Willow and Dawn are walking, Dawn tells Willow that she is going home. The monster comes up to them, and tells Willow that she summoned him. He scratches Dawn's face, and the girls start running. Willow opens a car and starts a car with magic, and the monster is following them. Willow is still acting goofy, and drives into a cement pole. Dawn gets out of the car to hide from the monster. Buffy and Spike hear yelling. The monster throws Dawn when Buffy and Spike appear.

The demon is destroyed by Willow, and her eyes are black again. Dawn is crying and hurt. Buffy anbd Spike start taking her away, and Willow jumps in front of her apologizing. Dawn slaps Willow, and she is on the ground weeping for forgiveness, and begging for help. At home, Willow is in bed and Dawn is going to be okay. Willow is telling Buffy that the magic got out of control, even before Tara left. She thinks she needs magic to be special. Willow announces that she is done with magic. Buffy agrees with Willow that it is over, while she is thinking about things with her and Spike, and how they are over. Later on, WIllow is going through withdrawal, and Buffy is in her room with garlic all around her.