Buffy is at her new job watching new training video for Doublemeat Palace. She meets Manny the manager. She is meeting the rest of the employees and they are acting blah. Manny offers her a locker that still has stuff in it, and he tells her that she can throw it all out. Manny shows her around. Buffy eats her first Doublemeat Medley. She is working at the front counter and her trainer, Gary, tries to take an order and gets overwhelmed.

Buffy is on her break and eating burger. She is looking in the freezer when Manny tells her she doesn't need to be in there. The gang comes to visit Buffy at her new job. Willow is antsy and Buffy is telling them she thinks something is wrong. Spike comes in to talk to Buffy and tells her she's better than this. Outside, Gary is attacked.

Buffy is working her second day at Doublemeat Palace. Manny tells Buffy that Gary didn't come in and she is being trained to grill. Many then tells Buffy she is working a double shift. At Xander's apt, a vengeance demon shows up and isprepared to turn Xander to bits when Anya tells her friend to lay off and they exchange hello's. She had summoned her friend to invite her to the wedding.

At work, Buffy goes on break and is having sex with Spike in the back alley. At the house, Amy visits Willow. Before Amy leaves, she casts a spell on Willow. Her eyes turn inky black and everything she touches is affected. At work, Buffy is watching the meat being ground. In it, she finds a finger. She confronts Manny because Buffy thinks the place is grinding people and she runs out and tells everybody their food is people. The old lady asks, "What about the cherry pie?"

Manny and other employees grab her and pull her back. Manny tells her she is fired. Anya is talking to her demon friend, and she is questioning her about Xander. Hally, her friend thinks that Anya is unhappy and Xander criticizes her. Buffy goes to the magic shop and had called emergency meeting. Xander and Dawn are there. Buffy brings back burger to see if it is people and Xander eates it. Willow runs into shop and analyzes the wrapper. Willow is still suffering from Amy's spell. Since it is after closing, Buffy will go back to Doublemeat palace. She is looking around and hears something. She finds a severed foot.

At the shop, Willow is using chemistry to analyze wrapper. Dawn is talking to Xander about how Buffy will not do much with her life, just jobs like this from now on. Anya comes into the shop. Xander asks her if Anya looked like her friend, all veiny, when she was a demon and Anya is offended. Willow finds out that the meat is not human, it is vegetable. Anya is making smart ass comments to Xander.

At Doublemeat Palace, Buffy finds a wig. It belongs to the old lady who orders cherry pies. She comes out and there is a demon snake that comes out of her head and Buffy is paralyzed.

The old lady wants to eat Buffy because she is full of doublemeat burgers. Willow goes to Doublemeat Palace and is telling Buffy the burgers are vegetable. She is also telling Buffy about Amy's spell. Willow is outside and runs in when she hears the noise. The snake thing is chewing on Buffy's arm. Willow severs the snake from lady's head and throws it into the grinder. Amy goes to Buffy's house, and Willow tells her that she can't come in anymore and that she better stay away from her.

At Doublemeat Palace, Buffy comes in to hand in her uniform. She meets the new manager, Lorraine. She heard about the scene Buffy caused. She also tells the manager she knows about the secret for the burgers. She tells Lorainne that she doesn't want to be fired anymore. Lorraine offers Buffy her job back.