Bad Can Be Good

Author: Dayna

E-mail: honzr@midstate.tds.net

Distribution: TPWFLD; otherwise, please ask.

Rating: PG-13

Disclaimer: All characters belong to Joss Whedon and Mutant Enemy. No copyright infringement intended.

Background: Angel has lost his soul and is hellbent on destroying Buffy. After Ms. Calendar is murdered and Spike and Dru are killed, Buffy decides she can't handle facing Angelus....the killer with her lover's face. Despite Giles' pleas, she convinces her mother to move far away. As a result, Giles is recalled to England to answer to the Watchers' Council about the Slayer's abandonment. Cordelia returns to her group of "friends" and vows to forget about the Slayer and Slayerettes. Oz graduates and goes on the road with his band. And Xander decides to go and live with relatives in another state. All of them leave without a backward glance to the one they left behind......Willow.

~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~

Summer 1998

It was a night when no human should be out alone. Of course, in Sunnydale, night isn't a time to be out alone or otherwise, unless you wanted to come face to face with the walking dead. Willow was more aware of this than anyone, but she didn't care. She stood on the edge of the bridge looking down, unaware of the rain or the cold wind, unaware of the shadow watching her. 

Angel stood in the shadows watching the young woman. What was she thinking, being out alone? She was easy pickings....maybe too easy. He knew the girl wasn't stupid, so why was she standing outside in this weather? Something wasn't right. With that thought Angelus laughed to himself. Walking quietly towards the former Slayerette, he decided it was meal time.

In some corner of her consciousness, Willow heard Angel's approach. And in that instance she knew she was going to die....and welcomed it. After all, it'd be easier than jumping. She felt him standing behind her and felt him grab her around the neck-and she did nothing.

"Aren't you going to struggle? Maybe scream?"

Willow just stood still and leaned her head to one side, exposing her neck to him. 

Angel was confused. The girl wasn't fighting him; in fact, she'd barely acknowledged that he was there. The only sign had been the tilt of her head, almost as if she was presenting him her throat.

"What game are you playing?"

Again, no response. She wasn't giving him the satisfaction of her fear. Was she even afraid? Angel got angry and spun her around to face him, making sure he had on his 'game face'. He looked straight into her eyes and what he saw made him step away. Willow fell to the ground. Instead of trying to flee, she sat up against the railing.

Angel had looked into her eyes and seen.....nothing. No spark of life, no light, no fear, no nothing. He looked at her sitting there, staring at something he couldn't see. He realized then that she wanted him to kill her. What the hell had driven her to offer herself to death?

"Willow?"

No response. Still she did nothing but stare straight ahead. No movement or sign that she'd even heard him. He knelt down in front of her and tipped her face so that she was looking directly at him. And he knew that if he could see his reflection in a mirror, his eyes would be a mirror of hers. And at that moment he knew he wouldn't kill her. "Go home to your nice little home and your little friends. There's no point in killing you. The Slayer's gone and it wouldn't accomplish anything. Count yourself lucky that I already ate."

Angel turned and started to walk away but something stopped him. A movement out of the corner of his eye. He turned, never expecting what he saw.

Willow had stood up but wasn't going home. She walked over to the railing and was climbing up.

Before he even knew what he was doing, Angel raced over and grabbed Willow before she could fall.

"What's the matter with you?"

Willow felt like a rag doll in his arms, and he unconsciously tightened his hold on her.

"Answer me!"

But Willow didn't hear him. She had retreated inside herself, trying to hide from the pain.

Angel knew he wouldn't get a response from her. He set her down on the ground and began to leave, but again something made him turn around. He walked back over to her and put his jacket around her shoulders, picked her up, and carried her back to his apartment.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Once at Angel's apartment, Angel put Willow into the shower; then dressed her in a dry t-shirt. He tried not to think about what a nice body she had as he dried her off and laid her on the bed. < What's the matter with me? Why am I playing nursemaid to her? >

But sitting next to her on the bed, all he knew was that there was something about her that made him feel protective of her- an emotion he hadn't felt since the curse was broken.

Angel pulled the covers up to her shoulders. What she did next took him completely by surprise....she gripped his hand in hers, brought it to her chest, and fell asleep. Angel didn't move for several moments, then went to sit in the chair and decided to try to get some sleep.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Several hours later, Angel was startled awake by moaning. He turned toward the bed and saw Willow thrashing about on the bed. Getting up, he walked over to the bed. Willow was sound asleep but obviously in the midst of a nightmare. Reaching out to brush a strand of hair from her face, he felt that her skin was ice cold. Without even thinking about it, he crawled into bed and pulled her into his arms. She burrowed against him and he tightened his hold on her shivering body.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Willow woke up confused and disoriented. The last thing she remembered was being on the bridge. Angel. It was then that she realized she wasn't alone. She turned and saw Angel. < What's going on? Why did he bring me to his apartment?> Willow reluctantly got out of bed even though she admitted to herself that she would've liked to stay in the bed with him, but no one else wanted her...so why would he. That train of thought brought about the depression of the previous weeks and she crawled into a corner and began crying.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Angel knew something was wrong when he woke up. It took him a moment to realize that he was in the bed alone. As angry as he was, it took him several minutes to notice Willow huddled in the corner. Angel wasn't sure why that thought pleased him. He walked over to the corner and shook her awake.

Willow looked into Angel's eyes. 

"I'm not going to hurt you."

He thought she wasn't going to respond but when she did it was barely a whisper.

"What?" he questioned.

"You made a mistake."

"What mistake are we talking about? I've made so many," he replied sarcastically.

"You let me live."

Angel was surprised. < Damn, this was becoming a habit.>

"Why's that a mistake?"

"I want to die. If you weren't going to kill me, then you should've left me to do it myself."

Looking into her eyes, he knew that she meant every word she said. He had never had anyone who wanted to die before. She was too young and full of life to want to die. < Funny, I've never thought about that when I've killed before. >

Again he asked, "Why?"

Willow looked at Angel. He wasn't acting like the Angel she knew before, but he wasn't acting like the killer that he was now either. And she realized that, for whatever reason, she wasn't afraid of him.

"Why what?" she answered.

"Don't get smart. Why do you want to die?"

"What do you care? Why didn't you make this easy for both of us and just kill me?"

"You answer my question and I'll answer yours."

Willow remained silent. She knew, compared to what he'd lived through, her reasons would seem stupid. But then, they were her reasons and they only had to matter to her. So she told him about being deserted by her friends, ignored by her family, and her feeling of utter loneliness. "I'm not strong like Buffy or Xander. Since they left, my world's fallen apart and I want the pain to end."

"You're stronger than both of them. Think about it. They ran away when things got tough; but, even though you knew what could and probably would happen, you stayed. That makes you stronger."

Willow just shook her head and began crying.

"You asked me why I didn't kill you, but I don't know if I can answer you. I was all prepared to until I saw your eyes. They reminded me too much of myself. For reasons I can't explain, I felt drawn to you and I couldn't allow anything to happen to you. That's why I brought you here, to keep you from jumping."

"You picked a hell of a time to try being a nice guy."

Angel roughly pulled Willow into his arms.

"I'm the same guy I was when I killed that teacher and tried to kill Buffy-certainly not a nice guy. And you'll do well to remember that. I haven't changed back into the wuss I was before that curse was broken. But for some reason, I can't kill you."

"Damn you, why not! No one else cares, why should you? They all left and made it clear that this place....including me, would be just a memory. You don't care about anyone, have no feelings, so why couldn't you just do what you're good at!" Willow yelled at him while hitting him in the chest.

Angel grabbed Willow's arms and pushed her to the floor, pinning her arms above her head and covering her body with his.

"That's enough! You know you can't fight me."

Willow stopped struggling and turned toward the wall.

Angel moved one hand to her face and turned it toward him, using his other hand to keep her arms pinned. Gently, he lowered his mouth to hers and kissed her.

"You need more rest. And I need time to think."

Angel lifted Willow into his arms and carried her back to bed. He crawled in behind her and slid her back against him.

"Goodnight Princess."

Willow and Angel laid in each other's arms, both confused about the events of the night. Willow knew that she should be afraid of him. After all he'd killed Ms. Calendar and tried to destroy Buffy. But of all the things she was feeling..none of them was fear. And Angel was trying to figure out what was happening to him. He didn't understand why he cared about what happened to the girl, but he did. He knew that he would kill anyone who tried to take her away from him. Whether he liked it or not, there was a bond between them. She belonged to him now.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Angel woke up and looked at the young woman sleeping in his arms. She had always been nice to him- never throwing his past back at him. She made him feel like he belonged with their group. That was one of the reasons, after the curse was broken, he wanted to kill her. But now, looking at her, he saw a beautiful woman. How could I not have noticed her? 

Willow woke to find Angel watching her. They laid there staring into each other's eyes. Willow finally buried her face into the pillow. "Why do you always do that?" he asked.

Willow looked at Angel in confusion.

"Do what?" she replied.

"Hide."

"It's what I'm good at."

Angel leaned over and brushed his lips over hers. Then turned the kiss into a passionate embrace.

"No more hiding." he admonished.

Angel got up and started putting on his shirt. He turned and noticed Willow watching him.

"What is it, Princess?"

Willow blushed at the nickname Angel seemed to have given her.

"You're confusing me."

"Well, the feelings mutual. But how have I confused you?"

"You're not acting like the Angel I met two years ago, but you're not acting like Angelus either. I know you're the same person who killed Ms. Calendar, but I'm not afraid of you. You're the one who killed my fish and tried to destroy Buffy; yet I feel safe with you. I don't understand it."

Angel walked over to the bed and sat down next to her. Reaching for a strand of hair, he began twirling it in his fingers.

"I'm Angelus. I haven't changed. I still kill humans, and I still plan to destroy the Slayer. The Angel you knew is dead and will stay dead, because I'm here to stay."

"Then why does it matter to you if I kill myself," she argued. "Angelus would jump at the chance to kill me, wouldn't he?"

Angel was not sure how to answer her.

"Yes, he would. Let's just say maybe, as far as you're concerned, I've picked up something from the old Angel. You touch something in me that I didn't even know existed, and I don't want to lose that. So I won't kill you, and I won't allow anyone else to hurt you either."

"So, what happens now?"

"I don't know, Princess. I just don't know."

Angel pulled Willow onto his lap and sat there just holding her. 

"You better get home before your parents call the cops," he suggested. Angel noticed a shadow cross Willow's face.

"They won't. Lately, they've been having problems and don't even realize if I'm around or not. Besides, they've been finding reasons to be gone alot. But, I should get going. School starts next week and I suppose I should get ready. Senior year is supposed to be the best time of my life, you know. What a joke!"

Willow got up and went into the bathroom to get dressed. She was combing her hair when Angel slipped his arms around her waist.

"This isn't over."

Willow nodded and turned to kiss him before she left. She knew now, without a doubt, that something had begun last night that would bind them forever. At the door, Willow turned to Angel. No words were exchanged, none were needed. Then the door closed and Angel was alone.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

The next two weeks passed in a blur. Willow went back to school, but nothing was the same. She no longer went to the library, and since Xander and Buffy were gone, she spent her days alone. Every once in a while she'd spot Cordelia; but she'd gone back to her 'in' crowd and wouldn't even acknowledge Willow. The days were lonely, but thoughts of the nights got her through. Ever since that night, she'd been spending the evenings with Angel. It had gotten to the point where she was practically living with him.....not that her parents even noticed. They were gone more often than not. Their relationship was still a puzzle to both of them but neither wanted it to end. Angel never told her what he did when he had to go out at night, and she never asked-it was better that way. And when they were together, it was magic. She'd never imagined that he could be such a gentle lover...her Angelus.

They had both agreed, for different reasons, that in those intimate moments she wouldn't call him Angel. He wanted to know that she wasn't confusing him with who he'd once been, and she didn't want the memory of Buffy's relationship with Angel to haunt them. Angel had become her life, in spite of what he did when they were apart. She loved him. And he let her know that the feeling, although a new one for him, was mutual.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Willow quietly entered their apartment; she knew Angel would be sleeping and didn't want to wake him. She couldn't face him....not yet. She set her bag down and sat to watch him sleep. 

So caught up in her thoughts, Willow didn't realize that Angel was awake and watching her. He knew the minute he saw her face that something was wrong. < She's afraid of something. If someone's hurt her, I'll kill them!>

"Princess?"

Willow raised her eyes to her lover and began crying. He held out his hand to her and she took it, joining him on the bed.

"What happened? You're afraid of something," he reflected.

Willow just nodded. < God, how I love him. How will I go on if I lose him now?" >

"Tell me. What are you afraid of?" he asked again.

"Losing you," she answered honestly.

"Where am I going?"

Angel noticed that Willow was fumbling with the blanket. He took her hands in his and gripped them.

"Willow, I can't help you if you don't tell me what's happened."

Willow stood up and walked over to wall and stood looking in the mirror. "I found something today," she explained. "My first impulse was to destroy it, but I realized that I couldn't make that decision. It had to be your choice."

Angel sat on the edge of the bed staring at her. 

"My choice about what?" he wanted to know.

"Whether you want to regain your soul."

"What!?"

Willow walked over to her bag and pulled something out. She handed it to Angel.

"A computer disk?"

Willow sat down in the chair and told Angel that Principal Snyder had given her the disk. It had been found over the summer and he put it aside for her.

"What's on it?"

"The Restoration ritual."

Angel was stunned. 

"Ms. Calendar must've saved it on the disk before you...before she died." Angel sat there stunned. Then something Willow had said previously surfaced in his memory.

"You were going to destroy it without telling me. Why?"

Willow swallowed hard. "Because I knew if you decided to use the ritual, that I would lose you. It would mean you....that Angel and Buffy could be together."

Angel didn't need to think about it. That part of his life was over. He had no desire to be reunited with the Slayer. He walked over to Willow and knelt in front of her. Waiting until she was watching him, he smashed the disk into pieces.

Willow looked from the smashed disk to Angel's face. With that gesture, he had closed all doors to the past, just as she'd done when she moved her belongings into Angel's apartment. Each was all that the other had. Angel pulled Willow to him. The kiss was just the beginning. He picked her up and carried her to bed. The choices had been made and they had chosen the same path. And no one would seperate them. They wouldn't allow it.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Several months later, Willow was sitting in the computer lab working on a project. Life at school was still lonely for her, but having Angel to go home to made it bearable. Willow was suddenly aware of someone behind her and spun around.

"Buffy? What are you doing here?"

Buffy didn't answer, she just stared at Willow. The Slayer had been feeling guilty about cutting ties with Willow. She had called her home, but couldn't reach anyone. As a last resort, Buffy had called Cordelia. She could still recall the conversation.

"She's what?!"

"You heard me. Willow's living with Angelus."

"You've got to be kidding. She wouldn't go near him. My God, he killed Ms. Calendar in cold blood!"

"Look, I don't have anything to do with Willow anymore, but I can tell you she's fine. He hasn't changed her and he apparently treats her well."

"It sounds like you approve. God, what's happened to you two?"

"Don't be so self-righteous, Ms. Vampire Slayer! You and Xander high-tailed it out of here when things got bad. Then Giles left too. Willow and I were left to fend for ourselves. I threw myself back into my old life and Willow found a new one. Besides, she's obviously good for Angelus. There have been no "unexplained" deaths since she moved in with him, other then the occassional lowlife. So, just go back to your new life and forget Sunnydale and forget us....you've done it before."

"Buffy?"

Willow's voice brought Buffy back to the present.

"Hello Willow."

"What are you doing back?"

"Well, I tried to call you and got no answer, so I called Cordelia, she had some interesting information about you."

"What kind of information?" Willow wanted to know.

"Information that I don't want to believe. Tell me you're not involved with Angelus."

Willow stood up and went to look out the window. It was just after sunset.

"It's true."

Buffy became angry.

"Damnit Will, how could you? He's a monster."

"Don't call him that. You don't know him like I do."

"Oh, please. Are you forgetting the people he's killed and the other horrible things he's done?"

"Of course not."

"I don't understand you. What happened to Oz?"

"He went on tour after he graduated and dumped me for some groupie. Funny, it was about the same time I was abandoned by my best friends." "So you turned to Angelus because you were lonely. God, get a dog!" "Just leave. You haven't been around, don't you dare judge me. You were the "chosen" and you ran. So don't lecture me."

Both girls were unaware of the shadow listening to their conversation . Buffy questioned Willow, "Do you love him?"

"Yes, more then life itself."

"And obviously more than your sense of right and wrong."

Before Willow could respond, Angel entered.

"Hello Buffy."

Buffy turned to see the new arrival. 

"Angel."

Angel walked over to Willow.

"Problems?"

Willow just shook her head.

Buffy turned on Angel, "I don't know what you've done to her, but it won't last."

Angel glared at her, "Listen carefully, Slayer. I'm only going to say this once. Leave Sunnydale now and don't return. I'm giving you this chance to walk away."

"Why not kill me? It's what you've threatened to do."

"Because killing you would make Willow unhappy and I won't do that. But don't push my generosity. Leave now or face the consequences," he warned.

Buffy turned to Willow.

"Willow, walk out with me now. Can't you see him for what he is?" Lifting her chin high, Willow countered, "I'm not leaving. I've made my choice. Do as Angel says. Leave and don't come back here."

"I won't leave you with him," Buffy vowed.

"Jealous?"

"Will, how can you ask me that? The man I loved is dead, and he killed him. I won't leave you here to be next!"

Willow shook her head sadly, "Why not, you left me before and never looked back. You had no way of knowing if Angel would come after me or not, but you still left without a backward glance. Well, you've eased your conscience, so you can go back to wherever you came from. I'm happy and healthy."

Angel ended the conversation, "You have 24 hours to leave."

Buffy watched Willow and Angel leave. Something about the way he held Willow brought back memories for Buffy. Was it possible that Angelus actually cared for Willow? Buffy turned and walked out of the school and headed away from Sunnydale, knowing she'd never be back. 

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Willow and Angel walked back to their apartment.

"Thank you," she murmured.

"For what, Princess?"

"Letting Buffy leave. I know that wasn't easy for you."

"It wasn't as hard as I thought it would be. Destroying the Slayer doesn't seem as important to me now. Besides, when Buffy left Sunnydale, she turned her back on her duties. She's a quitter, not really the Slayer anymore.

Angel stopped walking and turned to look intently at Willow.

"Did you mean what you said?"

"About what?"

"About loving me?"

"How long were you standing there eavesdropping?"

"Long enough. Quit stalling."

"I meant everything I told her."

"Good."

They walked the rest of the way in silence arms around each other. Just holding on to each other, they knew they had overcome a major obstacle.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Lying in bed with Willow, Angel thought back over the day's events. Seeing Buffy hadn't done anything for him. He had thought there would be disappointment at not being able to kill her. But ever since Willow had entered his life, his priorities had changed. Maybe the old Angel had the right idea about love-he just had the wrong woman in mind. Willow was everything he'd ever want. And when the time came, he'd bring her across. Because he had no intention of letting old age or death take his beloved princess away from him. Pulling Willow into his arms, Angel finally allowed himself to sleep.

Willow knew the moment Angel fell asleep. Looking at his relaxed face, she thanked whoever had given her his love. She knew he had done horrible things and that he had no conscience, but she also trusted his love. Besides, sometimes bad can be good. Curling up in the protective circle of her lover's arms, Willow drifted off into a peaceful sleep.

Both knew they would have problems to face, but they also knew that they could overcome anything. The power of their love had brought a touch of humanity to Angelus and a new confidence to Willow. They would face the future together.....a future full of love.

THE END

back