Set after "Normal Again". Spike left Sunnydale and has been gone for 5 years. He returns to track down and win Buffy back. What he finds when he gets there is the last thing he expected.

Disclaimer: Joss owns them, I’m just borrowing them to indulge my muse. Maggie, Chloe, and Alex are my characters, although you won’t really be seeing too much of Chloe and Alex.

Notes: This is a future-fic, taking place a little over 5 years after “Normal again”. It’ll also have some flashback scenes to explain the background, but I’ll be sure to let you know what’s going on in the notes :) Spoiler alert: any and everything on the show up until Normal again is fair game. It goes on it’s merry way after that. Please review, it encourages me to write quicker. Ok, here we go……..

+ + + + + + + + + +

Part 1:

Spike drove along the winding roads, coming upon a familiarly straight stretch of road. The August sun in the mid-afternoon should have been deadly, and he was thankful for the protection of his heavily tinted windows. His eyes drifted ahead and he laughed to himself at the previous fate that befell the landmark he gazed at. He pulled his car over to the side of the road, thinking how juvenile he’d been all those times before to try and destroy it, noting bitterly how it kept coming back like a Phoenix from the ashes. As he looked at the landmark, he started feeling a little uneasy about coming back here, wondering what he would find along the way.

WELCOME TO SUNNYDALE!” The white letters stared mockingly back at him. “Well, mate, it’s now or never. Might as well at least go and try to find her…”

Spike drove through the town of Sunnydale, noting that the more things changed, the more they stayed the same. The small downtown area looked almost exactly the way he’d left it, except that many of the buildings were showing the wear of 5 years of weather and use. He continued to drive, past the cemetery, wondering what happened to his old crypt. As he watched the sun sink to a nice, non-fatal level he parked his car in the exact spot where the old Desoto used to sit. Using the advantage of the daylight still left but knowing he was safe from any direct sunlight, Spike stepped from his car and let the California air warm his face.

Feels like a nice afternoon for a stroll” he thought to himself, and started walking down the sidewalk. He seemed to go on autopilot after that, heading straight for her neighborhood. The more he walked he started to doubt himself, and delved deep into thought as he stalked down the street.

*It’s been 5 years, mate. She’s probably moved on. Found herself a nice, normal bloke and moved into a big white house with a cute little picket fence. Why would she still be hanging around here, other than the fact that she’s still the slayer? She is still the slayer, right? I mean unless that Faith bird kicked it and someone else was called to take over.*

He slowed his pace a little, trying to settle his thoughts and gain some more of his confidence back. He started remembering happier times with Buffy, before she’d ended things for good and he’d left because the pain had been too much. He wondered if she ever thought of him. He wondered what he’d find once he made it to her house.

*Well, it’s the only shot I’ve got. I’ll just go there, see if she still lives there. If she’s not there, then I’ll just go on about my way and chalk it up to bad luck. Oh, but if she is there…* He turned his eyes up toward the clouds and said out loud “Please, if anyone up there is listening, please at least let her hear me out, if I find her.” The voice in his head picked up again. *Yeah, right. Why would she give you a chance? You did just what she thought you would. When the going got rough, you left, just like all the rest. You sodding, bloody, wanker…*

His self-belittling thoughts were snapped back to the present when he heard soft cries coming from just ahead. He stopped on the sidewalk and looked curiously at the site before him. A little girl was sitting in the grass beside the sidewalk with her little legs stretched out in front of her. When the strange man in black stopped in front of her, she turned her teary eyes up to look at him. She didn’t say anything, she just sat there, hiccupping with her sobs and letting new tears fall from her eyes. Her mommy had taught her to never talk to strangers, but this man was just giving off vibes that he wouldn’t hurt her.

In his entire existence, Spike had never seen a more beautiful child. Her skin was flawless, and was a perfectly sun kissed golden color *probably from playing outside all the time* he vaguely thought. Her ash-blonde hair fell to her shoulders in soft little curls, perfectly framing her tiny face. Even at her young age, she had these little cheekbones that gave definition to her face. Her green eyes sparkled back at him, shining even more brilliantly through her tears. She turned her head, and then he noticed that she had a tiny cut over her left eye, and a very small stream of blood was trickling down the side of her face, mingling with her tears and turning from crimson red to a watered down pink color. She then drew her knees up to her chest, and Spike noted that both knees were skinned. He didn’t want to frighten her, but he felt something tugging at his heart, making him want to help this beautiful little angel of a child sitting before him.

He sat down in front of her on the sidewalk, so he could be eye-to-eye to talk to her. “Are you ok, love?”

She once again turned her teary gaze to him, and shook her head “no”.

“Do you need help? Do you want to tell me what’s wrong?”

She studied him for a moment, trying to decide if her mommy would be angry with her for talking to this man.

On queue, as if he were reading her mind, Spike said softly “I bet your Mum told you never to talk to strangers, right?” She shook her head yes. “Well, then, let me fix that problem. I’m William. Now you know my name, so I’m not that much of a stranger, ok?” Again she shook her head yes. “Right then. So why don’t you tell me what’s the matter, and I’ll see if I can help you.”

Big tears welled in her eyes as she prepared to tell her story. As she started speaking, Spike was enraptured at the sound of her little voice. If he thought she looked like an angel, he thought she surely was an angel when her precious little voice started telling her story.

“Well, I was playing at my friend Chloe’s house, when she said her Mommy thought that my Mommy was weird. And that made me mad, so I told her that I didn’t want to be friends anymore, and I ran out of her house to go home, even though my Mommy told me never to walk home by myself.”

“Oh, that’s terrible, pet. But that doesn’t explain how you got these scrapes, dear. Want to tell me what happened there?”

She hiccupped again with a small sob, and continued. “That meanie Alex saw me and said he was gonna go tell my Mommy that I was out by myself, and I told him not to, but he said he was gonna go tell anyway, so I bit him.”

“You BIT him?”

“Y-yes. And then he started to cry and I ran away and he chased me. But then he caught up to me and tripped me, and I fell down on the sidewalk, and I hurt my knees and hit my head.” She was crying in full force again. Spike tentatively reached out and touched her hand, trying to soothe her cries.

“So what did this meanie Alex do then?”

“He was still crying ‘cause I bit him, and he ran into his house and left me here. And my knees hurt and I couldn’t walk home and my Mommy’s gonna be so mad at me and she probably won’t let me have my party next week and…”

“Hold up, love.” He smiled at her. “Let’s see what we can figure out. You know, don’t you, that you shouldn’t bite people. It’s not a very nice thing to do.”

“I know. My mommy tells me that all the time. ‘It’s not nice to bite people sweetie. We don’t hit or bite people, because we could hurt them’… she always tells me that whenever I hit Alex or bite him.” She smirked. Spike could have sworn this little angel *smirked* at him.

“Well, I have to say I agree with your Mommy. Are you feeling a little better than before?”

“A little.”

“Well, that’s good, pet.”

Again the little girl smiled at him. “I know your name now, but you don’t know mine.”

“That’s ok pet, you don’t have to tell me your name.”

“No, I want to. My name’s Maggie” Spike’s unnecessary breath caught in his chest. That’s who this little angel reminded him of: his little sister Margaret. He had always called her Maggie, and his mum had always hated it. Her little voice once again snapped him out of his thoughts.

“Will-yum? Will you take me home?”

“Uh, pet…Maggie, I would love to, but I don’t know where you live.”

“I know my address. Mommy taught it to me. I live at 1630 Revello Drive. Can you take me there?”

“I think I can manage that, Maggie.” Spike’s heart sank a little, knowing now that the love of his life had indeed moved on without him. He had no idea how he would find her now; now that there was a happy family with a precious little girl living in her old house. He scooped her up in his arms and started to carry her toward her house.

“How do you know which way to go?” She asked him when he instinctively headed toward her house.

“Oh. Well, you see, I used to have a very dear friend who lived in this neighborhood. In fact, that’s why I’m here in the first place. Was just coming round to see if she still lived here… was going to maybe pay her a visit. In fact, her address was the same as yours. So your Mommy and Daddy must have moved in there once she moved out.”

“Hmmm. Maybe!” she cooed. “But it’s just me and Mommy. My Daddy doesn’t live with us. I’ve never seen him, ‘cause he had to go away to work. He’s a hero, you know. Mommy always tells me how much she loves him and that he will come back someday. Hey! Maybe he’ll come for my party… ” She got a far-away look in her eyes, far more broody than any child should know how to be.

Spike wanted to cheer her up. “So, Maggie, tell me about this party that you’re worried about your Mommy taking away.”

Her eyes lit up again. “Oh, oh, oh! It’s my birthday; I’ll be five. And I’m having a big party, and all my friends are coming, except for now I’m gonna un-invite Chloe ‘cause she’s just as bad as that meanie Alex. But Mommy is making me let Alex come because she is friends with his parents. He’s a yucky, yucky boy.” She made a face and Spike chuckled at her impression of the young Alex, thinking ‘in 10 years she’ll probably have fallen head over heels for the git.’ She continued her story as they walked toward Revello Drive, telling him about all the games they would play at her party, and what kind of cake she wanted, and how much she hoped her mommy wouldn’t take the party away.

Spike noticed that her story seemed to be fading away, and he gazed down at her only to see that little Maggie had fallen asleep in his arms.

+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +

Meanwhile, about five blocks away, a young mother was on her phone, frantically pacing the floor. “What do you mean, she just left? How could you let a 5 year old just LEAVE your house by herself?”

“Honestly,” Chloe’s mom replied “ She ran out while I was getting the laundry. I thought the girls were playing in Chloe’s room until I went to check on them, and then Chloe told me that they’d had a fight and Maggie had left.”

“Well, we have to find her!”

“We will, you stay there, I’m sending Chloe’s dad out to look for her now. Keep your phone line free and he’ll take his cell and we’ll find her. Don’t worry.”

Maggie’s mom called Chloe’s mom back to see if they had spotted Maggie yet. As she was again becoming frantic on the phone, she was interrupted by a knock on the door.

“Wait. Someone’s at the door. I think she’s home. I’ll call you right back.” She went to the door, still holding the cordless phone in her hand.

+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +

Spike made his way up the sidewalk with the sleeping child in his arms. The cut over her eye was still oozing a bit, and her tears had not yet dried. She still managed to look so peaceful in her sleep, and he wondered how she had managed to fall asleep so quickly. He walked up onto the porch, wondering how he was going to explain to this little girl’s mother how he’d found her and why he’d brought her home.

He shifted the little girl in his arms to free up a hand to ring the doorbell, and watched as the small child curled up even more in his arms. He rang the doorbell and waited patiently.

Suddenly, the door burst open, and the frantic Mom called out before even looking to see who was there. “Maggie??” Then she took in the sight before her. A tall, blonde man dressed in black stood holding her daughter, and there was a small trickle of red on the side of her face and on her little knees.

Spike’s eyes flew wide when he looked at the woman standing in her doorway. “What the….” He was starting to say, when Maggie woke up and looked over to see that she was home.

A huge grin broke over her face, and she proclaimed “Mommy! Will-yum brought me home. Please don’t me mad at me, please, please, please.”

“Yeah, Mommy, please don’t be mad at her. She was hurt and I was only trying to help her.” Spike said as a smirk started forming on his face.

Buffy dropped the phone she was holding and fainted.

(TBC)

 

 

Part 2:

 

+ + + + + + + + + + + +

“Mommy!” Maggie shrieked, as she saw Buffy faint and hit the floor in the foyer. Spike panicked, not knowing if he could go into the house to help her, or if he’d been uninvited again after he left 5 years ago. He gently put Maggie down.

“Pet, you go sit on the steps, and let me see if I can help your Mum. I’ll be right back.” Maggie gave him a hard look, but then wandered across the porch to sit on the steps. Spike decided it was now or never. He reached out his hand, and let out a sigh of relief when his hand did not meet an invisible barrier at the threshold. He rushed in, and immediately fell to the floor beside Buffy, gently gathering her into his arms.

“Buffy, love, wake up. Please, wake up.” Her eyes began to flutter. “That’s it pet, wake up.” He looked out onto the porch, and called for Maggie. “Maggie, come here, pet. Your Mum’s waking up.”

Maggie ran over to where Spike and Buffy were sitting, and touched her mom’s face gently. “Mommy, what happened? You fell down like me!”

“Maggie?” Buffy’s eyes opened, and she looked at her little girl’s face. “Maggie what happened to you?!” She pulled away from Spike, and shrieked at him “What did you do to my little girl?!”

Maggie started to cry again. Spike never knew a child could start and stop crying so quickly. Buffy gathered her daughter in her arms and began rocking her back and forth. “Sweetie, don’t cry. Come on, calm down, try not to cry.”

The little girl placed her hands on either side of Buffy’s face, and looked at her. “Are you mad at me Mommy? Please don’t be mad. I know I’m not ‘sposed to walk home with out you and I know I’m not ‘sposed to talk to strangers but I fell down Mommy, and I was hurt and he helped me and please don’t take my party away ‘cause what if Daddy’s coming to it?”

Buffy’s heart skipped a beat. She looked back at Maggie and brushed her tears from her face. “No, sweetie, I’m not going to take your party away. And I’m not mad at you, but you scared me. I didn’t know where you were. Never, ever again go anywhere without telling a grown up where you’re going, Ok?”

“Ok, Mommy. You aren’t mad at me for letting Will-yum bring me home?” Buffy contemplated Spike, how he was just calmly standing there, taking in the sight of a Mother and Daughter, reunited.

“No, sweetie, I’m just glad he was there to help you.” She grinned to herself at how Maggie pronounced Spikes real name. Buffy looked up at Spike and he hoped that she just might give him that chance to explain that he was hoping for.

“You know what Mommy? Will-yum said he used to have a friend that lived in our house. And he was coming to see her, but she doesn’t live here anymore, ‘cause we live here now.”

“Is that so?” Buffy asked her daughter. “Well, why don’t we go into the kitchen and fix up your cuts and scrapes and William can tell us about his friend. Maybe we can help him find her.”

Buffy and Maggie started down the hall to the kitchen while Spike just stood in the doorway, amazed at how calmly Buffy was reacting to his return. He was sure he’d catch hell later, though, once Maggie was out of sight. Maggie turned around and noticed that Spike was not following them. She ran back and grabbed his hand, and tugged him down the hallway with her. “Come on Will-yum! You can tell me a story while Mommy fixes my cuts!”

Once in the kitchen, Spike lifted the little girl up to sit on the counter, while Buffy retrieved her first aid kit from the drawer. She got out the antiseptic, and Maggie winced and drew in a sharp breath before Buffy even got the bottle open. Buffy smiled at her, “Sweetie, I haven’t even opened it up yet, so it can’t hurt already.” Maggie opened one eye and looked at her mother warily. Buffy turned to Spike “Um, William, why don’t you talk to her, and maybe it will take her mind off of getting her cuts cleaned.”

“Ok.” Spike was suddenly at a loss on what to say to the child. I mean, he couldn’t just start telling her stories of his past like he used to tell Dawn…too much blood and guts for the bitty-Buffy sitting in front of him was definitely not the way to win Buffy over. Luckily, Maggie saved him,

“Will-yum, you talk funny. Why do you sound like that?”

“Well, love, I’m from a place called England. Do you know where that is?”

“Uh-huh! It’s where Giles lives! Giles is funny. He wears these glasses, and he’s always taking them off and cleaning them. Mommy says he’s always done that! He says there are real princesses that live in England. Is it true, are there really princesses there?”

“There sure are. There’s even a Queen and castles and palaces. Quite the fairytale land, it is.”

Maggie was so enraptured with Spike that she hadn’t even noticed that Buffy was finished cleaning her knees and had already put band-aids on them. She did notice, however, when Buffy touched the peroxide-soaked cotton to the cut over her eye. Maggie screamed immediately. Spike, without even thinking, took her little face in his hands and started to blow gently on her cut to soothe the sting. Buffy just watched in amazement at how tender Spike was being to her daughter.

Maggie closed her eyes and giggled, “How come your breath is cold? It tickles.”

“Just a little trick I learned once” Spike replied as he gazed at the child.

“So…” Buffy interrupted the tender scene, “Do you want to tell me how this happened, Maggie?” She gently placed a small band-aid on her daughter’s head and placed a kiss on the bandage.

“Will-yum knows. He can tell you.” Maggie was clearly trying to avoid telling her mother that she’d bitten little Alex Harris, causing him to push her down on the sidewalk.

“No, I think I want to hear it from you. I promise I won’t be mad at you, just tell me how this happened.”

Maggie began her tale again, about how she’d gotten mad at Chloe and left, and then ran into Alex on the way home. “…And he was so mean to me, Mommy, and he said he was gonna tell you and Auntie Anya that I was out and get me in trouble, and so I -bit -him-and-he-chased-me-and-pushed-me-down-and-that’s-how-I-got-hurt.” She rushed out the last part, hoping Buffy had missed the biting part.

Buffy had not missed the biting part. Spike was intrigued by the “Auntie Anya” part. *I guess the Whelp and the Vengeance Demon worked things out after I left…* Spike thought.

“You BIT Alex? Margaret Anne Sinclair how many times have I told you that you are NOT to bite people? No matter how angry you are or how much you think it will fix things??”

“I know Mommy, but he’s such a meanie, and he wouldn’t leave me alone. I hate him sometimes! I would hate him all the time if you didn’t like Auntie Anya and Uncle Xander!”

“Margaret…” Buffy warned. Maggie knew she’d gone to far- her Mom had used her real name twice already.

“I’m sorry Mommy. I will try very hard to never bite Alex again. But I won’t try to like him any better. He’s just a mean old yucky boy and I’ll never like him, never, never, never!”

“That’s it Margaret Anne. Go to your room while I start dinner. And no TV while you’re there. You can play with your coloring books but no TV. Now go.”

She hopped down from the counter and ran to the doorway. She looked up the stairs, and saw that the upstairs hallway was totally dark. She turned her slightly frightened gaze back to Buffy. “Mommy…it’s dark up there.”

Buffy sighed, remembering that the lights weren’t on upstairs yet. “Ok, I’ll walk you up. Come on.”

“Can Will-yum take me?” she said hopefully, knowing that she could probably con him into turning on her TV.

“Fine. He can walk you upstairs. But then I want him to come back. I need to talk to him about this friend of his that used to live here.” Maggie grinned and grabbed Spike’s hand, tugging him out toward the stairs.

Buffy called after them. “Sp-William…” He turned to face her. “She’s afraid of the dark, so turn on the light as soon as you get upstairs. And no matter what she says to you, do not turn on her TV.”

“Sure thing, love. Be right back.”

Maggie led Spike up the stairs, gripping his hand tighter as they ventured into the darkness. She stopped when they almost reached the top of the stairs, now fully cloaked in the darkness of the hallway. Spike reached down and picked her up. She put her arms around his neck and hugged him tightly, until he reached over and switched the light on.

“Which room is yours, love?” Spike inquired of the child. She pointed toward the door that used to be Buffy’s old room. Spike took her to the room, and smiled to himself when he took in the décor of the room. The walls were painted purple, with a lavender border around the wall, about waist high, and the sesame street numbers and letters stenciled in the border. In one corner of the room sat stuffed toys of each and every Sesame Street character, except for one, which resided on her bed. On the bed was the missing character; The Count. In fact, there were several versions of the count scattered about the room. The biggest one sat in the middle of the bed, smiling back with his fangs and cape billowing. Another, smaller stuffed toy Count lay on the floor beside her dresser, and looked as if she had carried him everywhere with her. All of the pictures on her walls were of the Count. He smiled at the irony of it all. She apparently loved The Count, yet had no idea that she had a real live vampire in her room.

He put Maggie down and she ran over to a little table and pulled out some coloring books. “Will-yum, do you like The Count?”

“Well, pet, he seems nice enough. I’ll bet you like him a lot, huh?”

“Yeah, he’s my favorite. He’s all fangy and ‘grr’” Spike chuckled at her use of Buffy’s old phrase. “Will you watch him with me on TV?”

“Now, love, your Mommy told me specifically not to turn on your TV. Seems that’s your punishment for biting young Alex.”

“Yeah, I know.” She whispered in defeat.

“I’ll tell you what. I need to back downstairs and chat with your Mum. So why don’t you sit here and color a nice picture of our friend the Count and I’ll see if I can talk her into letting you watch some TV before you go to bed tonight. Does that sound like a good deal?”

Maggie grinned and said “Ok!”

“Right then. You stay here and be good then, and your Mum will be up in a little bit when your dinner’s ready.”

Spike walked back down stairs and found Buffy humming and making dinner. She sensed when he walked in the door, and turned around to smile at him.

“Did she get settled in her room?”

“She did. We chatted about The Count, and she explained to me how he was all ‘fangy and grrr’. She’s coloring a picture of him as we speak.”

“Did she try to con you into letting her watch TV?”

“Of course. But I told her no, just like you instructed. But I sort of promised her that I’d ask you if she could watch a little while before her bedtime.”

“Well, we will just have to see about that. Spike, I really want us to sit down and have a nice, long chat. Why don’t you stay for dinner with Maggie and me and then you and I can talk after she’s asleep?”

“Ok, Buffy. I think I can handle that. There’s so much I need to tell you.” He seemed lost in thought again before continuing, “Ah, Buffy, you’re being a lot more rational about me showing up out of the blue than I had expected.”

“Spike, don’t start. We can both behave like adults here. And after Maggie’s asleep, we’ll sit down and talk. But for now, why don’t you tell me how you managed to find my wayward child this afternoon.”

Spike smiled and sat down at the counter to talk to Buffy, much like he had done before with Joyce. “Well, love, I was coming to town to see if I could find you, and while I was walking through your neighborhood I saw this little angel of a child crying by the sidewalk. I stopped to see if I could help her, and we became instant friends. And she wasn’t quite feeling up to walking, so I brought her home and now… here we are.”

“But how did you know she was my child?”

“Um, I didn’t Buffy. I didn’t know to which home she belonged until she spouted out her address for me. In fact, I was more than a little sad when she told me where she lived, because I thought that you had moved on.” He looked away from her, trying to hide the emotion in his eyes.

Buffy watched him intently as he described his encounter with Maggie. He sounded like he was genuinely concerned for the child, even before he knew whose child she was. Buffy wanted to tell him the truth right away, but was afraid of his initial reaction. She knew he wouldn’t believe her at first, but once she proved what she had to tell him, she didn’t know if he’d be happy or sad or angry, or indifferent. She decided to just plunge in and tell him.

“Spike, was there nothing that seemed the least bit familiar about her before you knew she was mine?”

“Actually, yes. I mean, there was something familiar about her when I first saw her, but then when she told me her name, it hit me. I never told you this, Buffy, but I had a little sister named Margaret. She reminded me so much of my sister, their resemblance is uncanny. I’ve never seen another child that was as beautiful as she was until I met your little Maggie today.”

“You met OUR little Maggie today, Spike.”

“Pardon me, love?” Spike sputtered out, thinking he misunderstood Buffy’s statement.

“Spike…Maggie is your daughter. Yours and mine.”

(TBC)

 

 

Part 3:

 

+ + + + + + + + + +

“Spike…Maggie is your daughter. Yours and mine.”

Spike sat there at Buffy’s kitchen counter and just stared at her, slack-jawed, with a sheer look of disbelief. *“well, that’s ok” Buffy thought “I knew that he wouldn’t believe me at first. But, really? Can’t I have some sort of reaction?” *

Buffy reached across the counter, and touched Spike’s hand. “Spike?? Are you ok?”

He blinked his eyes a couple of times and took a deep, although completely unnecessary breath. “Buffy, you know that’s impossible. Vampires can’t…”

“Well, you can. And you did. I promise you I’m telling the truth Spike.”

“Right Buffy. I’ve been gone for five years. So was this some sort of immaculate conception on my part? Did my thoughts from across the world create her?”

Buffy rolled her eyes. “Spike, do the math. You left Sunnydale in April. Maggie was born in August. Now, call me crazy, but the last time I checked a pregnancy lasted a little longer than five months. And trust me, I know. I went through it.”

“Well, pet, that still doesn’t tell me anything. Other than the fact that I must not have been the only one you turned to for comfort back then.”

Buffy walked around the counter and stood right in front of Spike. “Spike, please stop. I will not have you ruin what precious few memories I have of that time by accusing me of cheating on you. Spike, I’m telling you the truth, and if you would calm down long enough to listen and try to believe me, I can show you I’m telling the truth.”

“There is absolutely NO WAY this is the truth Buffy. As much as I would like to believe it, I know that it can’t happen. It never happened in almost 125 years, why would it suddenly happen now? And besides, that precious child upstairs told me all about her father while I was bringing her home, Buffy. So, aside from the fact that I KNOW it couldn’t be me, the fact that that little girl practically described Captain Cardboard to a tee confirms for me that I AM NOT HER FATHER!”

“Shhh! Will you keep your voice down? She will hear you and I DO NOT want her to hear this fight. Spike, if she heard you denying that you’re her father it would break her heart. And for the record, I resent the fact that you think I slept with Riley Finn while he was here that time. He’s married, for goodness sake. And still, do the math. It’s impossible.”

“Not as impossible as ME getting you pregnant.”

Buffy rolled her eyes. “And besides, what on earth did she say to make you think Riley is her father?”

“Plenty. She told me that he didn’t live with the two of you, because he had to leave for “work”. And she went on and on about what a great guy he was, how he was some kind of hero. Oh, and the kicker was when she told me how much her Mommy loved her Daddy, and how she would talk about him all the time. Now, pet, I know that you of all people would not use any of the above phrases to describe me.”

“You know, Spike, I think I’ve dreamed about the day you would come home even more than Maggie has. I always wondered how you would react, but I never, ever thought you’d be this stubborn. I knew that you’d probably not believe me at first, but I at least thought you’d give me the chance to explain and show you what we found, and then I had all these high hopes that you’d tell me you’d stay, and I could finally have my whole family together.” Buffy’s eyes clouded over with tears, as she turned to walk away from him.

Spike saw the tears forming in her eyes. He could only remember a couple of times when Buffy had let herself be so vulnerable that she’d let him see her cry. Then it hit him. He’d come here, hoping for a chance to explain to her why he left all those years ago, and where he’d been, yet he wasn’t even giving her the same chance. And, she wasn’t even demanding an explanation from him, she just wanted him to trust her. He reached out and caught her hand, turning her back to face him.

The phone rang, startling Buffy. She pulled away from Spike’s grasp to answer.

“Hello? Oh, hi Anya. Yes, she’s home. I’m sorry I didn’t call you and Jane to tell you, I just got so caught up in taking care of her and getting her settled down. How’s Alex? Anya, I am so sorry…are you sure he’s ok? Yeah, well Margaret has some serious apologizing to do tomorrow to everyone she hurt in this little fiasco.” Buffy’s call waiting beeped. “Anya, that’s my other line. I’ll call you in the morning, ok?”

Spike figured Buffy was engrossed in her phone calls, so he took the opportunity to slip out of the kitchen and upstairs. Buffy answered the other line, and turned around to find Spike missing.

“Hello?? Buffy, are you there?” Dawn’s voice crackled through the phone.

“Huh? Oh yeah, Dawnie, I’m here. Sorry was just a little distracted.”

“I’ll say. You sound so lost in thought that if I didn’t know better I’d think either Spike was back and sitting in your kitchen or that Riley showed up with yet another super-hero wanna-be wife.”

“Uh-huh,” was all that Buffy could think of to say.

“Oh, Buff, I’m sorry. I know that was a low blow. Listen, I just called to tell you that I’m running a little late from my lit class tonight, and I didn’t want Maggie to think I’d forgotten our weekly storytime. I should be there in about 30 minutes, though.”

“Right Dawn. Oh my gosh, I’d even forgotten that you were coming over tonight. You wouldn’t believe the evening I’ve had. Maggie ran away from Chloe’s this afternoon. Just be careful coming over and I’ll explain everything when you get here.”

“Buffy, is something else wrong?”

“Let’s just say you weren’t too far off earlier. I’ll see you soon Dawn. Bye.”

Buffy hung up before Dawn could respond, but her mind was reeling nonetheless. Knowing that the chanced of Riley being back again were slimmer than the chance that Spike had come home, Dawn made up her mind to get to her sister’s house as quickly as humanly possible.

+ + + + + + + +

Upstairs in the hallway, Spike stood beside the doorway to Maggie’s room. She had several coloring books scattered out around her, and she had retrieved the little Count doll from the place on the floor where she’d left it earlier that day. Spike gazed at her as she flitted around her room, playing and singing some song that he assumed was from Sesame Street. He tried to stand at the very edge of the door frame, so that he could see her without her seeing him. He kept playing Buffy’s words over and over in his head. *Maggie is your daughter, Spike * Then, he remembered Buffy calling Maggie by her whole name after finding out she’d bitten little Alex Harris. Margaret Anne Sinclair. What kind of game was Buffy playing, calling the child by *his * last name? Surely she wouldn’t go so far with this joke that she would confuse the child. Spike’s mind was still reeling as he stared at Maggie in wonderment. She did remind him of his own sister. He had felt some inexplicable pull toward her, even before he knew who she was. She had his cheekbones, and Buffy’s eyes. Spike knew that he still needed the whole story, but the more he stood there and watched her play, the more he wanted to believe that she was his. He’d never even imagined that he’d have a family, other than the messed up, dysfunctional version of a family he’d had with Angel, Darla, and Dru.

Buffy walked slowly up the stairs, not wanting to disturb Spike. He looked like he was deep in thought as he stood in Maggie’s doorway watching her. Spike felt her presence, though, and turned toward her, motioning her forward. He was so filled with emotion at that moment that he could barely speak around the uncharacteristic lump that had formed in his throat.

“She’s really mine?” He managed to whisper to Buffy when she reached his side.

Buffy reached out and took his hand in hers. “Yes, she’s really yours. Spike you have to know that I would not lie to you. Not about this.”

“But, how? I mean, I have it on very good authority that vampires are not…um, set up to have babies.”

“I’ll explain it all to you after dinner… that is, if you’ll still stay. Dawn’s on her way over to spend some time with Maggie, so we can talk while Maggie plays with Dawn. Ok?”

“Ok. Buffy. Nibblet is coming over? Gosh, I can’t even imagine how much she’s grown up in 5 years…” he trailed off.

The two started back down the stairs to check on dinner before retrieving Maggie from her room. Just as they reached the kitchen, the front door swung open, and Dawn breezed in, calling for Maggie.

Maggie rushed down the stairs, and jumped into Dawn’s arms. “Auntie Dawn! You’re late,” she said, matter-of-factly.

“I know sweetie, I had to stay at my school a little longer tonight. How was your day? I hear you ran away?”

“Yeah, I did. I also bit Alex. That’s how I ended up with this cut on my head.” Dawn tried to hide a giggle as she listened to Maggie describe her afternoon as if it were a normal everyday occurrence. Maggie frowned, then smiled again when she remembered the rest of her story. “But I made a new friend!”

“You did?” Dawn asked as she put Maggie down.

“Yes, he helped me when I fell and he brought me home. I think he’s still in the kitchen with Mommy. You have to meet him.” Maggie took Dawn’s hand and dragged her into the kitchen much like she’d done with Spike earlier.

“Mommy?” she called loudly down the hall. “Is Will-yum still here? I want him to meet Auntie Dawn!”

Just as they reached the kitchen, Dawn realized that Maggie had just said her new “friends” name was William at the same time that she saw a familiar blonde head turn toward the door way.

“Will-yum… this is my Auntie Dawn! Auntie Dawn, this is Will-yum. He has a friend who used to live in our house, and he likes the Count, just like me!” she beamed.

Spike grinned. “Hello Lil’Bit”

Dawn couldn’t speak. She just stood there, holding Maggie’s hand, staring at Spike, and feeling very much like she might faint.

TBC….

 

{Next}