|
| |
|
Why did Serenity Fail?
Check out Alex Epstein's opinion on why he believed Serenity Failed at the box office!! His blog is entitled: Complications Ensue - The Crafty TV and Screenwriting Blog |
Friday, July 14, 2006
SECOND GUESSING
Why do you think SERENITY failed at the box office?
I'm going to say: because it was episodic. There were something like four self-contained episodes in the story. Each resolved almost completely, leaving just enough plot to ignite the next episode. So the movie didn't feel like a coherent story. It felt like a bunch of television episodes rammed together.
Also, Joss's cast of TV actors didn't exactly ignite the screen. They just didn't feel larger than life. That's why I think it failed.
Now, a couple of caveats: did SERENITY fail? After all the DVD sales are in? And the foreign sales? I don't know. It cost about $40M. Made about $25M box office and $15M overseas. Those are box office numbers so the studio gets, say, half. But then it probably made another $20M easy on DVD sales and TV, not to mention any merchandising. I doubt anyone on the show was entitled to gross points, so the studio got to keep more of the money than it would have on a $150M Harrison Ford picture. I would bet the studio's internal accounting shows a slight profit.
More importantly: I don't know why the hell it failed. Movies with terrible scripts hit. Why did My Big Fat Greek Wedding make $100M at the box office instead of oh, say, $5M? Was it twenty times better than the next charming indie romance? My memory was it had almost no plot, and was stunningly short on obstacles. I'm sure I could have fixed the script, made it a better movie, and turned it into much less of a hit. Was Blair Witch actually a good picture? Would it have made $100M the summer before? Or the summer after? Or would it have disappeared into the cut-rate DVD bins?
People watch for stories, but they also watch for characters and spectacle, and because other people are watching. And movies with good scripts fail. As a writer you have to believe that a good script is better than a bad script. But there are other factors at work, so don't get too big a head on behalf of us writers...
What do you think of Alex' opinion on the matter?
| | [by Roisin (blogspot.com) ] [5 comments]
|
| brutal_affection | 15.07.06 - 11:57 | | i havnt seen a single episode of firefly but i bought serenity and loved it! i guess you either love it or hate it. | | hogwaffle | 15.07.06 - 16:47 | I dont agree. I can't see where the 4 supposed episodes are in the movie, at most I could break it into three parts (Which could just be begining middle and end) And I think that the cast did ignite the big screen. When I first saw this movie and first saw them on screen I can't even describe the feeling it gave me. Yes I am a fan, but I brought many a clueless person to the theater and they all enjoyed the movie if anything I think the movie "failed" theatrically because Universal hardly advertised for it, and the trailers were crap, I beleive this movie will be one people find on showtime and wonder how the hell they missed it in theaters.
As a side note here is an alternate trailer I made http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4hcmriehjCg | | Edgeoforever | 15.07.06 - 19:21 | | One word: Promotion (lack of) | | Willowtree | 16.07.06 - 01:35 | | Did it really fail? | | rt | 16.07.06 - 08:31 | | It failed because it wasn't any good. |
You have to be logged in to comment. | |
| AD | 
|
| |
Buffy the Vampire Slayer, its characters, and the Buffy logo are the property of Joss Whedon, Mutant Enemy, the WB Television Network, and Twentieth Century Fox. Angel-The Series, its characters, and the Buffy logo are the property of Joss Whedon, Mutant Enemy, the WB Television Network, and Twentieth Century Fox.Other Series, their characters and logos are property of the proper right owners.
(c)Slayerverse 2006 [Imprint] |
