BUFFY: Ok. I think Jonathan might be ignoring evidence. I think he might have let Tara get hurt.

WILLOW: On purpose?

BUFFY: No! No.

GILES: How did he ignore evidence?

BUFFY: The monster had a mark on it. Jonathan saw it a-and he kind of... blinked.

XANDER: He blinked? The man moistened his eyeballs and we're having a meeting about it.

BUFFY: Wuh. He knows something about the monster. He was reacting to the mark. Oh!!! Wait, I remember something. Giles, do you have a Jonathan swimsuit calendar?

GILES: No. Yes. It was a gift.

(Buffy flips through)

BUFFY: No. No. Whoah! No. There.

WILLOW: (dismayed) Oh.

ANYA: Yeah. Pretty darn lickable.

WILLOW: The other kind of oh. That's it that's what Tara saw.

written by: Jane Espenson; Transcribed by Corwin2. Full transcript at:
http://www.studiesinwords.de/73superstar.html