JENNY: Those creeps left this behind.

BUFFY: What is it?

GILES: I have no idea. Can, can it be opened?

BUFFY: Yeah. This looks like a release right here.

(arm in the box starts choking Buffy; eventually gets crammed back in)

XANDER: Well, clearly the Hellmouth's answer to 'what do you get the Slayer who has everything?'

GILES: Good heavens. Buffy, are you all right?

BUFFY: Man, that thing had major grip.

WILLOW: W-what was that?

OZ: It looked like an arm.

ANGEL: It can't be. She wouldn't.

XANDER: What, uh, vamp's version of 'snakes in a can', or do you care to share?

BUFFY: Angel?

ANGEL: It-it's a legend... way before my time... of a demon brought forth to rid the Earth of the plague of humanity... separate the righteous from the wicked... and to burn the righteous down. They call him the Judge.

GILES: The Judge? This is he?

ANGEL: Not all of him.

BUFFY: Um, still needing backstory here.

GILES: Um... He, he, he couldn't be killed, yes? Um, a-an army was sent against him. Most of them died... but, uh, finally they were able to dismember him, but, uh... not kill him.

ANGEL: The pieces were scattered... buried in every corner of the Earth.

JENNY: So all these parts are being brought here.

BUFFY: By Drusilla. The vamps outside were Spike's men.

ANGEL: She's just crazy enough to do it.

WILLOW: Do what, reassemble the Judge?

ANGEL: And bring forth Armageddon.

CORDELIA: Is anybody else gonna have cake?

written by: Marti Noxon; . Full transcript at:
http://www.studiesinwords.de/25surprise.html