Cordelia gets out of the Driver’s Ed car and shuts the door. In the next scene, the door is open.

Why is there no passenger-side brake pedal in the Driver’s Ed car? It would have enabled the teacher to safely bring the car to a stop.

Did Catherine Madison have the same last name before and after her wedding? Her school cheerleading trophy says ‘Catherine Madison’ but she won this before she was married.
It’s possible that Catherine changed her name back to her maiden name after her husband left her and made Amy do the same …

Before the group performance in cheerleading tryouts, Cordelia is seen putting a pink headband on. Then while she’s cheering it’s no longer there. When Amy falls on her, Cordelia has the headband back on.

This is not necessarily a goof but it’s something which bugs me everytime I watch The Witch. We see Amber doing the splits and stretching whilst resting her feet on two chairs. How did she get on and off the chairs? We see her standing shortly after the Scoobies pass …

Cordelia says she is going to the Bronze that Friday, the night of the Harvest. Oddly, everyone is back in school the following day.

Buffy stakes an off-screen vampire using a pool cue in the Bronze. He falls back but we don’t hear him turn to dust.

Cordelia clearly states that Friday night is no-cover night at the Bronze… so why is everyone paying money?

Luke is burned by the cross that Angel gave Buffy, allowing her to escape from the tomb. In the next shot, we see Buffy running away and the necklace has disappeared.

Darla doesn’t seem to know what a Slayer is but we know from future Buffy and Angel episodes (such as Fool For Love) that she does. She should have known straight away that Buffy is the Slayer.

When Willow and Buffy are talking in the Bronze, Buffy has a drink with a straw and some cherries. In the shots where we see Willow, Buffy is sometimes eating a cherry or drinking from the straw, but in quick cuts to Buffy’s face, she’s not. This occurs a few …

In The Bronze, there is a close-up of the drummer playing. The beat in the song and the drummers hands are out of synch.

When Buffy and Giles are arguing about Buffy being the Slayer, Giles hands her some books. When he gives them to her the spines of the books are facing one way and when she gives them back to him they are facing the other way. They alternate like that a …

Darla’s bitemarks on the dead boy run horizontally. It would be impossible for Darla to have positioned her head to get bitemarks like this.

When Buffy drops her purse on the floor, there’s a girl in a striped skirt in the background walking down the hall. In the next shot (where we see Xander) the same girl is walking down the hall but in the opposite direction.